The Best Budget Baking Sheet: Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Half Sheet
When considering quality and price, Nordic Wares popular half sheet pan is a great option thats nearly identical to the Misen pan. The most noticeable difference is that the 18-gauge uncoated aluminum is somewhat lighter than the 16-gauge Misen, but its still thick enough to be warp-resistant at high heats. It reliably produces evenly-cooked food at both high and low temperatures, though we found it cooked sugar cookies a little more quickly than the Misen, resulting in a cookie that was just a smidge too dry when cooked using the same time and temperature . Until this year, it had been our top pick, and while it didn’t quite outperform the Misen in our testing, it was a very close second that we still enthusiastically recommendespecially because you get two Nordic Ware pans for the price of one Misen.
Like the Misen baking sheet, the Nordic Ware pan is made from bare aluminum, which is easy to scratch and stain. But for an uncoated pan, its fairly easy to clean too. Luckily, natural wear generally wont lead to undesirable results when cooking and baking, but if you crave a clean slate these dont cost much to replace.
Rachael Ray Nonstick Carbon Steel 3
This 3-piece set comes with small, medium, and large baking pans as well, all of which are made from durable carbon steel that resists warping. The pans have a long-lasting nonstick finish to provide excellent food release, making for easy cleanup.
Ive used Rachael Ray products in the past and I have never been disappointed. I usually feel pretty confident buying products promoted by people who cook a lot.
These pans are dark in color, and they hold heat well. Theyre rimmed with extra wide handles, making them very easy to pull out of a hot oven.
Plus, they provide a pop of color, which I always appreciate. You can choose from a selection of color options for the handle grips. These would make a nice gift for the baker in your life.
- Set includes a variety of sizes: 9 x 13, 10 x 15, and 11 x 17 inches.
- Rimmed edges keep baked goods from slipping off.
- Extra-wide handles help to easily grab pans from the oven.
- Nonstick material helps to quickly clean and remove food.
- Also available in a 5-piece set, should you need a bigger selection.
If youre thinking about these pans but youre not totally convinced, another nice thing about them is that a portion of the proceeds go to Yum-O!. Rachaels nonprofit helps kids and parents to develop healthy relationships with food, which is something future generations really need.
Gotham Steel Nonstick Copper
When I first laid eyes on this product, I got really excited because Id never seen a copper baking sheet before. But alas, these are copper in color only.
Nonetheless, this pan is a unique option in the ceramic category. Its made of something different, and perhaps far more interesting, than copper would be.
Comprised of aluminum coated with a Ti-Cerama surface, titanium is combined with ceramic to create a durable and nonstick product.
Measuring 18 by 12 inches with a 1-inch rim, this pan is dishwasher safe, oven safe up to 500°F, and you can even use metal utensils on it without having to worry about scratches.
The nonstick coating is chemical free, it wont peel, and the manufacturer claims that you wont even need any butter or oil to grease this baby up its plenty nonstick on its own , so you can save a few calories.
Its thick with a sturdy rim so it wont warp, even at high temperatures. It will look nice alongside those copper pans in your collection even though it isnt really made of copper .
- Wont warp, even at high temperatures.
- Aluminum with Ti-Cerama coating is durable and nonstick.
- Dishwasher safe.
- Scratch resistant, and you can use those metal utensils.
Has this pan piqued your curiosity? Find out more now on Wayfair.
Don’t Miss: Is The Lena Baker Story On Netflix
Bottom Line Up Front Our Top Rated Model
We believe the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Bakers Half Sheet is the very best for baking cookies, for most people.
Its made from natural aluminum, which tells us its durable and not coated with any toxins, but it will still hold up well in hot environments.
Although its a bakers half, it fits nicely in a standard oven. Based on our in-house testing, it can hold about 20 round treats at once, if you use about a tablespoon of dough per cookie, made from a batter that doesnt spread significantly during baking.
This sheet might be the only one youll ever need, but its so nice you might want to buy two. You have that option. But if youre looking for pans that come conveniently packaged as a set, keep reading for some of our favorites.
Our top pick from Nordic Ware is commercial quality and guaranteed never to rust. Its also made in the USA and is priced rather low, so even the most budget conscious shoppers can surely justify this purchase.
It does well at your average 350°F, but has been shown to hold up nicely at higher temperatures upwards of 500°F as well, which is perfect for roasting sweet, caramelized vegetables or making pizza.
This product is .
If youre looking for a high quality sheet thats built to last, this Nordic Ware pan is a good option for most bakers.
Is Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Bakers Half Sheet 2 Pack Silver Available And Ready For Delivery In In Great Britain
desertcart ships the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Bakers Half Sheet 2 Pack Silver to and more cities in Great Britain. Get unlimited free shipping in 164+ countries with desertcart Plus membership. We can deliver the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Bakers Half Sheet 2 Pack Silver speedily without the hassle of shipping, customs or duties.
Read Also: Elf Baked Highlighter Moonlight Pearls
Design: Classic And Versatile
If youre looking for classic sheet pans, these fit the bill. They are the standard half-sheet size with flat surfaces. The edges are slightly sloped to make transferring food off the sheets easier. These smooth rolled edges make the baking sheets easy to transfer in and out of the oven. They also stack well and, as a result, are easy to store in cabinets or under the oven.
The only thing I didnt like about the design was the stamped logo on the top of the tray. This makes it difficult to clean and leaves imprints on more delicate foods like cookies, cakes, or croissants. Because of this, you will most likely want to use parchment paper or silicone mats when baking with these sheet trays.
Despite not having a nonstick coating, the sheets released food easily.
Anolon Nonstick Steel 3
If youre in need of multiple pans, this might be the product for you, since it comes as a set of small, medium, and large for a total of three. All are made of steel and they are nonstick with a bronze-toned coating to provide even baking and browning, and a nice rim. Or, if you prefer, theyre available in a graphite color as well.
The price for all three pans is one of the lowest I have seen, which has me wondering How do they do it?
Overall reviews are positive, and happy customers are pleased with their durability as well as the ease of stick-free cooking.
Though these pans are technically dishwasher safe, hand washing is recommended. If you treat your cooking equipment with care, and you appreciate the versatility of different size options, this might be a wonderful set for you.
- Great value, with 3 sheets for less than the price of 1 from other brands.
- Nonstick material makes cleanup easy.
- Heavyweight material holds up to 450°F and its warp-resistant.
- Set includes 3 sizes: large , medium and small .
They stack very well, so if space is an issue in your kitchen, you dont have to worry with these. If youre trying to find an overall good deal, look no further than this set.
Also Check: How To Bake Frozen French Fries
Why Trust The Spruce Eats
The author of this piece, Bernadette Machard de Gramont, is a Los Angeles-based writer who specializes in global food and wine content. After a two-year stint at the Williams-Sonoma Headquarters in San Francisco, she now researches and tests a variety of cookware, bakeware, and wine tools, and interviews field experts for their insight. She interviewed one expert, Clemence Gossett of Santa Monica-based The Gourmandise cooking school, for this piece.
Donna Currie, who updated this roundup, is a cookbook author who writes roundups and reviews products for The Spruce Eats. She has tested more than 100 kitchen products for the brand, including the half sheet pans featured on this list.
Carrie Honaker, who also updated this roundup, is a food writer, restaurateur, and avid home cook. Her work has appeared in many publications, including Bon Appetit, Allrecipes, and Wine Enthusiast.
How We Tested The Baking Sheets
Within the catch-all sheet pan categorywhich includes full sheet pans, half sheet pans, quarter sheet pans, jelly roll pans, and rimless cookie sheetswe only tested rimmed half-sheet trays with rolled edges. Theyre what we use in the Epicurious Test Kitchen and what most home cooks use, whether they call them sheet pans, baking sheets, or cookie sheets.
To test bare aluminum baking sheets, we first placed empty, room-temperature pans in a 450ºF oven set to convection-bake. We left them in for ten minutes and listened for a loud pop that would indicate warping. None of the pans we tested in 2022 warped in testing. We left the oven set at 450ºF and cooked lightly-oiled and seasoned broccoli, cauliflower, and onion directly on the ungreased pans. We observed how evenly the food cooked on each. After the pans cooled, we attempted to clean each with just a cellulose sponge, dish soap, and hot water.
We then used store-bought sugar cookie dough and baked cookies on each pan according to the instructions on the packagewhich, for an uncoated, ungreased pan, was 350ºF for 12 minutes. We removed each to a cooling rack and after cooling inspected the cookies for evenness, texture, and color, and noticed how much the cookies stuck to the pan and how easy it was to clean each pan by hand.
Everything was tested on its own on the middle oven rack for consistencys sake and the oven was allowed to return to its target temperature between batches of cookies and vegetables.
You May Like: Knorr Cheddar Broccoli Pasta Bake Recipes
Competition: You’ve Got Options
TeamFar Baking Sheet: Generally, I’d reach for the Nordic Ware over the TeamFar sheet except on days where I’m feeling extra lazy or working with acidic foods. The TeamFar baking sheets are made with nonreactive stainless steel and are dishwasher-safe.
OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Half Sheet Pan: Although more expensive, the OXO sheet pan outperforms the Nordic Ware with all its bells and whistles. While it may have more advanced technology, the OXO tray is much heavier than Nordic Wares classic aluminum style.
A solid sheet pan.
The Nordic Ware Naturals Baker’s Half Sheet is made with commercial-grade aluminum, so it’s more durable and sturdy. Although the embossed logo can cause slight problems, this sheet pan heats up evenly to cook foods and cleans up just as easily.
- Product Name Naturals Baker’s Half Sheet
- Product Brand Nordic Ware
- Product Dimensions 11.3 x 16.3 x 1 in.
- Material Aluminum
$25 For Two At Amazon
Nordic Ware has earned plenty of accolades online and for good reason: It is an outstanding balance of function and form. And like that slumber party classic, the aluminum sheet pan is light as a feather and stiff as a board. But what made this a no-brainer? Its one of the least expensive pans we tested.
Nordic Wares half sheet is only rated to 400 degrees Fahrenheit, yet it didnt warp even at 450 degrees Fahrenheit. One possible explanation? The pans rim is reinforced internally with galvanized steel wire, which helps it keep its shape.
The bottom of the pan remained flat at high temperatures, which was nice for keeping tomatoes from rolling or cookies from sliding in one direction. The embossed logo on the bottom of the pan is slightly raised, so it did trap some tomato juice and grease.
The sheet pan gave carrots a lovely char and roasted tomatoes without leaving behind blackened skin. Cookies were evenly cooked and golden brown on bottom. There were no hot spots and the rapid cooling of the pan meant the cookies didnt get too crispy.
The uncoated surface had to be hand-washed but browned bits came free with water and a soapy sponge. There were a few light scratches and some slight discoloration, but nothing that would impact the performance of the pan.
This baking sheet earned top marks for roasting tomatoes and it looked good doing it. The Williams Sonoma sheet pan is dishwasher-safe, but the effective nonstick surface means you can easily scrub it clean.
Read Also: What Is In Chili’s Baked Potato Soup
Six Ways To Use Your Baking Sheet
Now that you know which sheet pans to buy, it’s time to put them to work. Here are some of our favorite ways to use this versatile piece of cookware.
If youre already using a sheet tray for anything other than making cookies, youre probably using it to roast vegetables, right? For extra-crisp roasted vegetables, put the sheet tray in the oven while it preheats so its nice and hot. This is especially good for potatoes, but you can really roast anything on a sheet tray. The fact that the sides are only an inch high means that more direct heat can circulate around what youre roasting, yielding crispier surfaces all around. So much better than roasting in a deeper roasting or baking pan.
Line a sheet tray with a clean dish towel and spread freshly washed herbs, greens, veggies, or berries out to dry.
You want air to circulate all the way around foods that will release liquid while they roast , so the food gets crispy instead of cooking in its own juices. The solution? Fit a wire rack into your sheet tray and proceed with roasting. This is great for baking breaded cutlets or for finishing a pan-seared a pork chop in the oven. This is also the best way to cook crispy bacon for a crowd.
You dont need a pizza stone to make great pizza at home, just heat an overturned sheet tray in your oven as hot as it will go and spread the dough on top for thin crust pizza, or bake it inside for a thicker grandma-style pie.
Farberware Nonstick Steel 3
If a silvery hue is more in line with your kitchen aesthetic, try this set from Farberware. Three matching nonstick steel pans with 1.5-inch rims are included in this set a large 17 L x 11 W pan for baking cookies, and smaller 15 L x 10 W and 13 L x 9 W pans for roasting veggies or reheating leftovers.
These pans have a shallow moat around the flat surface inside, to catch the liquid runoff from juicy foods. And theyre from Farberware, a trusted brand in this category for over a century. Dishwasher safe, though hand washing is recommended.
- Steel with nonstick coating is oven safe up to 450°F.
- A variety of sizes offers versatility, with good value for the price.
- Easily stackable for storage.
- Rimmed edges keep baked goods in place with no risk of drips.
If youre looking for a heavy-duty product from a brand you can trust, give this set a try.
Read Also: Great British Bake Off Watch Online
Cooking Performance: A Job Well Done
As expected, the Nordic Ware baking sheets performed like most other aluminum sheet trays I had used before. Its real benefit lies in its durability and design. The baking sheets conducted heat evenly and well but werent as fast at heating up compared to the OXO pans I own . While many online reviewers reported warping, I didnt experience thiseven at extreme temperatures.
Despite not having a nonstick coating, the sheets released food easily. However, a lot of residue would stick when baking directly on the pans. This didnt impact the quality of the food nor was it difficult to clean off. However, I wouldnt recommend this for avid bakers, especially if making something as delicate as macarons. When the tray is unlined, the stamped logo sticks to softer foods like baked goods.Given the logo is a few inches wide, that would be about two or so cookies worth of space youd be losing. However, if you dont bake often, you shouldnt have a problem with other foods, like meats or vegetables.
If adding the Nordic Ware baking sheets to your kitchen, you may also want to consider having another set of sheet trays as well. Since aluminum is a reactive metal, these sheets shouldnt be your choice for roasting tomatoes or cooking lemon-marinated chicken thighs.
Made with professional-grade pure aluminum, the Nordicware baking sheets are extra durable.
The Spruce Eats / Samantha Schwab