Cake Bake Shop Carmel Indiana

Must Try

Top 3 Reasons To Eat Here

Cake Bake Shop’s Carmel hiring event

Always heard great things about this establishment, I was looking forward to the experience. I’m totally NEVER going back. We had made a reservation for 4 and added on the reservation that there would be a baby with us. When we arrived, I believe the…manager, her name was Cindy welcomed us, telling us , while displaying her attitude. that the table they were going to put us at wouldn’t fit with a high chair, and that they would have to move us , we explained to her that we had put on the reservation that a baby would be with us. She stated that they didn’t know if the reservation was for 3 with a baby or 4 with a baby. Clearly they didn’t look at the information we sent. She then took us to a room , stuck us in the corner and not so nicely told us that the room would be full in 30 minutes. Not sure why she felt it was necessary to tell us that , the room only 3 people in it when we were seated and only 2 people in it when we left an hour later. Very disappointed in the treatment we received and will never be going back.More

Hi, and thank you for your feedback regarding your experience. We did respond to your review on another platform as well. Did you speak with a manager during your reservation? We would have been happy to exchange any items for you. We have sent your…More

Making Dreams Come True

When you arrive you walk through French doors, sparkling chandeliers over head, antiqued mirrors, French inspired furniture, beautiful seasonal decorations, gorgeous cakes on French porcelain platters topped with glass domes. Gwendolyn’s shops offer the most incredible experience from The Best Quiche You Will Ever Have to homemade soups, salads, sandwiches, even a true French Croque Monsieur. Behind the kitchen window you can see the master bakers gently sieving non-bromated flours from Vermont, there are large pots of French & Belgian Chocolate melting on the stove, cakes baking in the ovens and decorators frosting the most exquisite cakes.

Gwendolyns Cake Bake Shop’s have become the destination of Indiana for celebrating birthdays, anniversaries and all the special occasions life offers.

‘Dream it, Do it’-Marty Sklar.

Gwen..You are unbelievable!!! Honestly the best cake ever!!! My guys looooooved it. Keep that one on your menu!!! Can’t thank you enough. Highlight of the day:) Your the best! Thanks.

Alison, Indianapolis

Cake Bake Shop…love it, amazing chocolate cake!!!! I would fly the pond for a slice of that.

Peter Sidwell, TV host of Britains Best Bakery

Since her shop opening in 2014 she has been recognized for the following:

Oprahs ‘Favorite Things’


Williams-Sonoma, Pottery Barn Teen, Costco and Tiffany & Co.

All of her retail items are now available in the Gift Shop.

Meet My Family

Believe in yourself

The Cake Bake Shop Carmel

COVID-19 update:Read more#19Restaurants in CarmelImprove this listingTravel Safe hub

  • Face masks required for staff in public areas
  • Hand sanitizer available to guests & staff
  • Daily temperature and symptom checks for staff
  • Socially distanced dining tables
  • Staff required to regularly wash hands
  • Tables disinfected between guests

Recommended Reading: Baked Pork Chops With Apples

The Cake Bake Shop: Life Is Even Sweeter In Carmel

Writer // Janelle Morrison Photography // Staff

Once there was a place where people would gather, engage inthoughtful conversation in an elegant setting and enjoy a delectable meal froma scratch kitchen. Patrons over several decades contributed to an exquisitetapestry of memories that makes the L.S. Ayres Team Room legendary. In myopinion, since the famed tearoom closed in 1990, there hasnt been a place thatmatches its former splendor, until now.

As her existing fans know, Gwendolyn Rogers opened The Cake Bake Shop in 2014 at the Broad Ripple location. She recently opened her second location in Carmel, where The Cake Bake Shop glistens while nestled in the heart of City Center. Rogers attention to architectural detail is equal to her passion for details regarding incomparable comfort food and impeccable service. The Cake Bake Shop in Carmel is proof of that. Upon my first visit at the Carmel location, I was spellbound. It is wonderment redefined and evokes a welcoming environment to all who stroll through its doors.

The Ingredients that Make a Fairy Tale

Ive just evolved as Ive grown, Rogers said. When Ifirst started, I didnt have this big grandiose plan that I wanted to open thisbig restaurant and be a restauranteurthat was not part of my plan at all. I justwanted to create a place where I could do what I like, and what I like to do iscook.

The Cake Bake Shop in Carmel

A Place to Build Memories

Sharing The Years Of Christmas Past

Indianapolis restaurants: Cake Bake Shop in Carmel is beyond gorgeous



The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers has been recognized as a 2021 Travelers’ Choice award winner. This achievement celebrates consistent delivery of fantastic experiences to diners from around the globe. This award is based on a full year of reviews and ratings from the people who matter the most, their guests. This award speaks to the great service and experience provided to their guests. This ranks The Cake Bake Shop among the top 10% of restaurants listed on Tripadvisor. That is something to be very proud of!

Gwendolyn proudly announces

Her Cake Bake Shops Are Now An Exclusive Partner With Williams-Sonoma

She has become an Exclusive Partner with Williams-Sonoma, with over 36 homemade dessert items selling on the Williams-Sonoma website, shipping nationwide.

Don’t Miss: Tate’s Bake Shop Southampton

Restaurants Near The Cake Bake Shop

0.1 miles0.1 miles0.1 miles0.1 miles0.2 miles0.2 miles0.6 miles0.6 miles0.4 miles0.4 miles0.6 milesAmericanIrish

Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.Reset zoom

This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.more

Frequently Asked Questions About The Cake Bake Shop By Gwendolyn Rogers

Does The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers take reservations?

Yes, you can make a reservation by picking a date, time, and party size.

Is The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers currently offering delivery or takeout?

Yes, The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers offers delivery.

What forms of payment are accepted?

The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers accepts credit cards.

How is The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers rated?

The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers has 4 stars.

Also Check: Baked By Melissa Upper West Side

Review Of The Cake Bake Shop

112 ReviewsPrice range:Description:Restaurant detailsDescription:Delicious!

Today was our 1st visit to the new Carmel location. We have been to Broadripple previously and been pleased. The Carmel location is breathtaking. So beautiful! Parking was also easy. The location is a bit hard to find so be mindful of that. It is tucked inside a building structure. Our server was very attentive and professional once he arrived. We were seated about 15 minutes before he greeted us. We also waited about 15 minutes past our reservation time to be seated which was reasonable. The chicken velvet soup and chicken salad croissant were show stoppers! Our lunch was delicious!! We were also very pleased with the cheesecake and the millionaire cake. Our only disappointment was that the award winning mint chocolate chip cake was not available. Our reservation was early in the day so I would not have expected anything to be sold out. He simply said it’s not at this location. I am not sure if that means never or just today. If running out of food is a problem I would suggest limiting walk-in bakery orders so that guests with reservations are given the full experience. The server did say they were short staffed so that may have been the problem? Overall I would recommend going at least once to experience this beautiful restaurant. It would also be lovely to offer a tour of the basement/bakery so we can see things in action! I missed that piece from your other location here.

  • Value

Experience The Magic Of Gwendolyn’s Shops

Cake Bake Shop, Carmel Indiana

Gwendolyn’s Cake Bake Shop Tiaras Have Arrived

Featuring an intricate rhinestone design that forms two beautiful swans that adorn the top of each crown. The Cake Bake Shop logo is in the center with pink stones. Your King, Queen, little Prince or Princess will love and cherish this Cake Bake Shop keepsake. Perfect for celebrating birthdays, baby showers, anniversaries, weddings and bachelorette parties.

Available in child and adult sizes.

Top Work Places 2021 USA

USA Today Network names The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers a winner of the ‘Top Work Places 2021’ award

We are excited to announce that we have been awarded Top Work Places 2021 by USA Today. We employ over 169 team members in the state of Indiana. We offer full health benefits, 100% match 401K and paid vacation. It is also the most magical place to work with an incredible group of people.

Oprah’s Favorite Things 2019!

The Rachael Ray Show

Gayle King & Oprah’s Creative Director for ‘O’ Magazine, Adam Glassman, Share 9 Gift Picks-Gwendolyn’s Crumb Cake Is A Top Holiday Pick.

Don’t Miss: Baked Kraft Mac N Cheese

About The Cake Bake Shop

The Cake Bake Shop prides itself in creating magical and one-of-a-kind experiences to guests, who come from near and far to celebrate the big, and small, moments in life.The Cake Bake Shop started as a small shop in Broad Ripple Village in Indianapolis and continues to grow to new heights each day, which comes with limitless potential for career growth, in almost any direction. The Cake Bake Shop strives to put employees first when it comes to growth, and always posts open corporate/management positions internally prior to allowing outside applicants.The Cake Bake Shop was named a top workplace in Indianapolis in 2020, and prides itself in creating a positive and enjoyable work environment for employees. The Cake Bake Shop provides medical, dental, vision, life, and ancillary insurance to full-time employees, as well as paid time off, and company matched 401k .

Pay: $55000 – $65000 per year


Gwendolyn’s Ros Bubbles Have Arrived From France

Gwendolyn’s Cake Bake Shop has partnered with Jean Charles Boisset of the Boisset Wine Family to showcase their Rosé Sparkling Wine from the Burgundy valley in France. The color and exceptional quality of this Crémant embodies the style, sophistication and elegance that The Cake Bake Shop is known for. From the vineyards of France all the way to your table. Celebrate life! Available for purchase in both shops and for delivery within the metro area of Indianapolis only.

Don’t Miss: Simple Truth Organic Aged White Cheddar Baked Puffs

Popular Articles

More Recipes Like This