Baked By Melissa Cupcakes Reviews

Must Try

Our Baked By Melissa Review

Baked By Melissa Cupcakes in 12 Flavors Review

We had the opportunity to try an assortment of Baked By Melissa cupcakes. What a treat!

I got excited when I saw the bright red box get delivered to our door. I can only imagine what an awesome treat it would be to send these to someone as a surprise gift.

My excitement grew as I open the packaged and pulled out the bright tie-dye box inside. The tie-dye box is very sturdy and you just slide the cupcakes right out from the side opening. Very handy.

The company specializes in shipping cupcakes across the company and it shows. The packaging design not only keeps the treats in good shape, it also helps ensure freshness.

You can see in the picture below that even after getting jostled around during transit and flipped around for my photos, the treats arrived in really good shape.

Even those little guys in the middle that turned sideways still had their fluffy frosting intact!

We enjoyed a 25-pack that contained all the tried and true favorites like tie-dye, red velvet, peanut butter and jelly, cookie dough, mint cookies, cookies and cream, chocolate chip pancake and triple chocolate fudge.

This flavor assortment provides a great mix of classic vanilla and chocolate cake, plus other fun tastes like mint, pancake and red velvet.

For frosting, some had chocolate or vanilla icing, while a fair amount had other specialty flavors like peanut butter and maple.

Our pack also contained the mini of the month, Toasted Cinnamon.

Review Of Baked By Melissa

so much more fun than the full size overpriced cupcakes in NY. great flavors and moist instead of the dried out ones we have had oher places. Worth a stop!

  • Value

277281 of 385 reviews

oh wow. we were amazed at just how adorable these tiny little cupcakes were! They were the smallest desserts I’ve ever seen…and yet…so good. We couldn’t believe just how much flavor was packed into each tiny bite. Enjoy!

Stumbled across this place and decided to give it a try. Don’t be fooled by the word “cupcake” – because these are more like thimbles! And you are paying $1 each for them! The ones I got were even smaller than the ones in the photos here – barely an inch across. Very cute, I’ll give them that, but when it wasn’t even enough for two bites I’d say kitchey doesn’t trump value. And to be honest, the quality was OK but nothing earth-shattering compared to other gourmet cupcakes I’ve had. Save your bucks for some other snack, would be my suggestion!

  • Value

New Flavors Seasonal Flavors And Mini Of The Month

The real magic happens with the ever-changing rotation of seasonal and holiday flavors. Plus new flavors are coming out all the time with their mini of the month.

You can even talk a walk down the Flavor Hall Of Fame to see past flavors like cake batter crumble, tie-dye smores, Lucky Charm, cornbread crumble, cotton candy and Oscar the Grouch! If youre looking to place an order of 300 or more cupcakes, you can request any of these past flavors.

Thats the beauty of Baked By Melissa. There are always new and unique flavors of delicious mini cupcakes to keep you coming back for more.

Don’t Miss: No Bake Recipes For Kids

What I Didn’t Like About Baked By Melissa Holiday Cupcakes

  • The range of flavors. The one big thing I noticed while trying out the cupcakes was the prevalence of chocolate, which is not a negative by any means, but I did notice that the chocolate cake flavor seemed to dominate both boxes. If someone in your life loves chocolate cake, they’ll be pleased, but otherwise they may be a bit disappointed by the spread.
  • The emphasis on packaging * This is a small complaint, but it would have been exciting to see a wider variety of holiday flavors, rather than a wide variety of holiday boxes.

Baked By Melissa Review

Baked by Melissa

Based on online research and 68 Baked by Melissa reviews, Baked by Melissa’s overall score is 4.2 out of 5 stars. Baked by Melissa’s review score is based on Baked by Melissa’s customer ratings, its brand popularity, its price competitiveness, as well as the breadth and quality of features it offers to customers. The Baked by Melissa review table below incorporates summarizes 68 Baked by Melissa ratings on 1 features such as products made in USA, and . You can also compare Baked by Melissa against popular alternatives likeNothing Bundt Cakes, Insomnia Cookies and Send a Cake. or you can view the top 50 brands in similar categories, such as , and .

Don’t Miss: Baked Spaghetti With Ragu Sauce

Is It Worth It A Review Of Baked By Melissa

Baked by Melissa is at 14 locations, mainly based in Manhattan.

If youve ever spent some time in Manhattan, odds are youve passed by Baked by Melissa. Placed at smart, busy locations, it is rather easy for you to fit in a visit the next time you take a trip to the city. You may have noticed them before or heard about the shop as it is pretty well known.

Should You Buy Baked By Melissa Cupcakes

How could you say no to these cupcakes?

Baked by Melissa cupcakes areand Im so sorry for the punan absolute treat. Theyre cute, tasty, and a joy to receive. Id not only buy them again, but Id highly recommend sending them as a gift to coworkers, friends, or loved ones, especially if they are also afflicted by a loud and demanding sweet tooth.

Would I personally still buy them again at that price point? Absolutely, just not as often as Id like.

The product experts at Reviewed have all your shopping needs covered. Follow Reviewed on , , and for the latest deals, product reviews, and more.

Read Also: How To Bake Squash In The Oven

What Cupcakes Can You Buy From Baked By Melissa

Baked by Melissa released a number of holiday-themed cupcakes.

Baked by Melissa prides itself on its unique flavorsyou wont find standard chocolate and vanilla cupcakes here. Instead, youll be treated to cookies and cream, peanut butter and jelly, chocolate chip pancake, and even caramel hot cocoa. New flavors pop up each season, so keep your eyes peeled for new flavors as the months tick by.

Buyers can pick their favorite flavors and customize a pack of cupcakes for themselves, or they can opt for the Latest & Greatest Cupcakes, which feature a mix of new and popular cupcakes from the brand. And mercifully, for those who are gluten-free, Baked by Melissa offers a range of gluten-free cupcakes featuring top-selling flavors like red velvet, triple chocolate crunch, and birthday cake.

Unique And Creative Flavors To Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth

Baked By Melissa Review: Are These The BEST Mini Cupcakes? ð§?

Baked By Melissa offers some popular customer favorite flavors year-round. Their most famous sweet treats are their signature tie-dye cupcake.

Some other popular flavors are peanut butter & jelly, chocolate chip pancake, mint cookie, cookie dough, red velvet, triple chocolate fudge and cookies & cream.

They also offer plenty of special dietary options like bite-size cupcakes that are gluten-free and vegan. Most of their flavors do not contain tree nuts, but its important to note that they are processed in a kitchen where nuts are used.

Recommended Reading: How To Bake Frozen Lasagna

What Is Baked By Melissa

Baked by Melissa is a New York-based business that sells tiny treats.

Baked by Melissa makes and sells tiny treats, namely cupcakes and macarons. It was founded by Melissa Ben-Ishay in 2008, and since then, the brand has expanded to include 14 locations and nationwide shipping. The cupcakes themselves come in packages of 25, 50, and 100, while certain holiday packs come in smaller sizes.

Cupcakes from Baked by Melissa are smallwere talking literal bite-sized treats. Each cupcake is made without paper and topped with a dollop of icing , making them extremely snackable.

Each package of cupcakes comes in a plastic container with domed tops to keep each cupcake held tightly in place without ruining decorations. You can also order special packaging for any cupcakes, including holiday and birthday boxes.

Baked By Melissa Locations

While having cupcakes delivered to your doorstep is a convenient option, you might want to visit a cupcake shop in person.

All of their sweet treats are baked at one central location and delivered fresh to their stores on a daily basis.

How many Baked by Melissa locations are there?

The company has 14 store locations in the New York City and New Jersey areas.

Be sure to check the store locations map on the company website for up-to-date details.

Don’t Miss: Nyt Baked Mac And Cheese

Baked By Melissa Review: Baked By Melissa Pros & Cons

Baked by Melissa is an extremely popular cakes & cupcake store which competes against other cakes & cupcake stores likeNothing Bundt Cakes, Insomnia Cookies, Send a Cake, Mrs. Fields and Great American Cookies. Based on our in-depth Baked by Melissa review, when compared to its competitors, Baked by Melissa is a lower-performing brand within its category, with an overall ranking of #5 out of 0 total brands. Read the full review below for more details.

  • Products made in USA: Are each store products made in the USA? Does each store manufacture their products in the United States?
  • :
  • :
  • :

Knoji has 68 Baked by Melissa reviews and ratings as of June 26, 2022. Knoji editors and the Knoji shopper community have reviewed Baked by Melissa and compared it against 0 top brands, reviewing Baked by Melissa based on product and store features such as domestic production policy, and . Knoji reviews and ranks and other cakes & cupcake stores based on how many features each offers and based on a 5-star rating scale. Based on these factors and 68 Baked by Melissa reviews, Baked by Melissa earns an overall score of 4.2 out of 5.0 points. Baked by Melissa offers 0 total features such as , and . Baked by Melissa’s’s review score is also bolstered by the fact that it is a very popular brand with high brand recognition among consumers.

What Comes In The Baked By Melissa Holiday Collection


The Baked by Melissa holiday collection features holiday-themed gift boxes that include the curated selection of holiday cupcakes or the regularly featured Baked by Melissa cupcakes. The holiday gift boxes include festive colors and patterns and support cupcake packs of 25, 50 or 100 cupcakes. You can also get three-packs of mini cupcakes.

Also Check: Honey Baked Ham Snellville Ga

What Id Change About Baked By Melissa

These tiny cupcakes pack a lot of flavor in each bite.

As with any relationship, I hold a lot of love for Baked by Melissa, but there are a few things I dream of changing. Namely, the pricing. Baked by Melissa is on par with its high-end baked good competitors, including Milkbar and Jenis. The difference is that you can crush a package of Baked by Melissa cupcakes in one evening , whereas with Milkbar or Jenis, you get enough treats to last several days.

One 25-pack of cupcakes from Baked by Melissa starts at $32, but if you live outside of the New York or New Jersey area, shipping starts around $15. That means for 25 mini cupcakes, youll pay about $50. Its less expensive than a cake from Milkbar or a pack of ice cream from Jenis, but still more money than an average buyer may be willing to spend.

Baked By Melissa Reviews Faqs

Baked by Melissa has an overall rating of 2.8 out of 5, based on over 182 reviews left anonymously by employees. 31% of employees would recommend working at Baked by Melissa to a friend and 47% have a positive outlook for the business. This rating has improved by 1% over the last 12 months.

According to anonymously submitted Glassdoor reviews, Baked by Melissa employees rate their compensation and benefits as 2.6 out of 5. Find out more about salaries and benefits at Baked by Melissa. This rating has improved by 1% over the last 12 months.

31% of Baked by Melissa employees would recommend working there to a friend based on Glassdoor reviews. Employees also rated Baked by Melissa 3.2 out of 5 for work life balance, 2.7 for culture and values and 1.8 for career opportunities.

According to reviews on Glassdoor, employees commonly mention the pros of working at Baked by Melissa to be coworkers and the cons to be career development, senior leadership, benefits.

Don’t Miss: Honey Baked Ham Littleton Co

What I Liked About Baked By Melissa Holiday Cupcakes

Don’t sleep on the Carmel Hot Cocoa cupcakes.

Apart from the absolute joy of opening the front door to find a box of delicious cupcakes on my front steps, here are the things I enjoyed most about the Baked by Melissa holiday cupcakes:

  • The holiday flavors tasted like what they claimed. One thing I really loved about the holiday flavors was how evocative they were of the actual things they claimed to be. Really, the brightest star out of the two boxes was the Festival Babka cupcake, which was the favorite not only for me, but for the three other individuals that happened to try the cupcakes over the course of the day, and had the cinnamon-y, buttery elements of a real babka. The Caramel Hot Cocoa flavor was a close second, and with the addition of the sweet little marshmallow tasted very reminiscent of a mug of hot cocoa.
  • The packaging. The presentation of Baked by Melissas cupcakes is something weve talked about before, but having never ordered them myself I was extremely impressed by the packaging they came in and the quality of the holiday boxes.
  • The freshness of the cupcakes. Since I live in New York City, I can’t vouch for the quality of the cupcakes once they’ve been shipped cross-country, but our initial reviewer noted that the cupcakes that she received tasted “like they came straight from a nearby bakery.”

Baked By Melissa New York City

Baked by Melissa Mini Cupcake review

My husband and I stopped here briefly since we noticed a sign that said “vegan” cupcakes. We went in and learned that they were the only one of this chain that carries vegan cupcakes. They have regular ones as well plus they make party packs…for special occasions such as graduations.The vegan cupcakes are made with almond milk and a substitute ingredient is used for eggs. We were permitted to sample one of our choice since they came in only 6 flavors. My husband had a peanut butter and I had a chocolate chip one. They were basically only 1 bite. Cost for these cupcakes is $3.00 each. The others you can get 2 for close to $3.00. While they were good still that seems so little for what you are spending.Nevertheless as with everything vegan prepare to spend more if you prefer that type. They do not permit sampling of the regular cupcakes so you would have to purchase it and take your chances.The morsel was just enough to satisfy our sweet tooth. I inquired about transporting it and was told that without refrigeration they would only last a day. So much for bringing one home with me.Baked by Melissa is a chain dessert shop you would find all over the city. It is very small but carries a wide assortment.More

Also Check: Honey Baked Ham Woodbridge Va

Should You Buy Baked By Melissa Holiday Cupcakes

If you’re looking for a gift for the sweet treat lover in your life, a kind gesture for a friend, or simply a gift for someone for a Secret Santa or holiday exchange, these cupcakes might be the move. The Festival of Bites pack, especially, is a crowd-pleaser that I highly recommend.

The product experts at Reviewed have all your shopping needs covered. Follow Reviewed on , , , TikTok, or Flipboard for the latest deals, product reviews, and more.

Everything I Loved About Baked By Melissa

Cupcakes from Baked by Melissa arrive in attractive packaging.

As I mentioned above, I am a huge sweets fan. I learned how to bake as soon as I moved out of my parents house because I didnt want to live in a world where I couldnt have immediate access to baked goods at any given time. As a result, Ive become picky about which pre-made treats Ill buy for myself since I learned I could get superior desserts by just making them at home.

All that being said, cupcakes from Baked by Melissa exceeded my expectations. These tiny treats tasted like they came straight from a nearby bakery, despite the fact that they were shipped from New York City. Each cupcake was deliciously moist and flavorful, and even though they were bite-sized, they delivered an immense punch.

Specifically, heres where Baked by Melissa excels:

You May Like: Bak Bakflip Mx4 Hard Folding Truck Bed Tonneau Cover

How I Tested Baked By Melissa Holiday Cupcakes

The cupcakes arrived on my doorstep in what I can only describe as a very exciting pink box, and after determining that Id been sent the correct packages I gave the cupcakes a try. In terms of selection, I received:

In the past, we tested out the Holiday Cheer pack as well as the Latest & Greatest Cupcakes, Birthday Cupcakes, and February Fix Cupcakes.

To test them, I ate the cupcakes. Full stop. I spent an entire day haunting boxes of festive cupcakes, which was, in itself, not a bad way to spend a workdayfor you, of course, dear reader.

Popular Articles

More Recipes Like This